I’ve lost count of the number of articles that pop up in search for the best spas in the UK. Most of them read as though one of the country’s finest spas has been ranked highly within the country’s best spas. Take the Punchline Gloucester coverage of Hatherley Manor being shortlisted for a spa award among the UK’s top hotels.
A place as a finalist is something to be proud of. It also means something different to a top rating, placing the spa among a strong list of finalists.
Why headlines turn finalists into winners
Readers remember the word ‘best’ and largely forget the word ‘finalist’ that follows it in the body copy. Therefore a shortlist becomes a verdict to remember. The headline is generous, and the shortlist behind it is a real achievement. There is no doubt that a finalist in a highly regarded program is something to shout about, and it reflects a public vote.
What the feature actually reports
The Spa at Hatherley Manor has been shortlisted as a finalist for the Best Hotel Spa (Boutique) category of the Good Spa Guide Awards 2026. For the purpose of the shortlist for these awards guests and spa lovers have been able to vote for their favourite spa until 5pm on Monday, August 31. The boutique category only includes spas found within a boutique hotel.
Best means different things to different readers
The term ‘best’ refers to a number of very different things – a quiet thermal suite to use for your spa breaks in Gloucester or perhaps a swimming pool and gym to use as well. The ASA’s guidance on ‘best’ claims covers these as objective claims and then also as a number of subjective claims.
The ASA’s guidance on award-based claims is of relevance here.
What the spa’s own wording gets right

Jackie Armitage, Spa Manager for Hatherley Manor Hotel and Spa is right when she says that being shortlisted with some of the best spas in the UK is an ‘honour’. The words of the Spa at Hatherley Manor are far more measured and accurate than the headline of the feature. The words of Jackie Armitage also describe the experience that she aims to deliver to her guests – welcoming, relaxing etc. These are subjective qualities that guests can judge for themselves.
Reading shortlists with the right weight
By reading a headline which states that a spa is one of the best you need to look at what that means i.e. best at what, a particular measurement, a selection of other Spas and who selected them. In this case it means Boutique hotel Spas, a public vote and the other finalists on the shortlist.
So long as you read shortlists with the right amount of respect, you will find that a place as a finalist alongside other good spas is a real mark of quality for The Spa at Hatherley Manor. Book on what the spa offers and you can choose a break that suits your needs, the services you require and your budget.
Leave a Reply